|
Post by Praline on Feb 24, 2006 15:20:04 GMT 10
I've never been a Carby, I've never remotely liked Carby and i'll never understand Carbies. BUT... even if I did I think that Carter was more in love with the idea of Abby, not Abby herself. He only really became interested in her when he saw her in the AA meeting and it spiraled out of control from there. The reason he didn't propose to Abby was pretty much because when he was talking to Maggie she said that Abby didn't need changing, she is great the way she is. It was then Carter realised that she wasn't the person he had imagined her to be inside his tiny little brain! So he didn't do it and it all unraveled from there (thank God!!!, the madness was almost over) The whole letter thing really pissed me off too, and not just because it was such a juvenile thing to do but also because he had to of known it would have hurt Abby to have it end like that AND who the hell would send it to the ER? Idiot! He knew how nosey Frank was!!
|
|
|
Post by dosia on Feb 24, 2006 20:44:30 GMT 10
They were just sweet I loved them! I'm afraid you're right... Anyway - during his relationship with Abby he was very stupid and irresponsible. And nothing will change it. But i still think he is a great character LOL
|
|
|
Post by elicia on Feb 24, 2006 23:20:33 GMT 10
They were just sweet I loved them! Okay you're being sarcastic here? Some of them are sweet because they're delusional (just like I used to be during the Carby time), but most of them are just tiring and their comments manage to p** off every time!
|
|
|
Post by dosia on Feb 25, 2006 0:24:22 GMT 10
No, I'm not sarcastic LOL I really think that they were great together, but their friendship during s7 was much better that their relationship... John Carter was a part of the show since the first episode and I can't imagine how you may not like him... Sorry, but it's strange for me Do you remember when he stayed with a sick girl (befr her transplantation i think) in season 2? He didn't go for his diploma... It was sweet. Or when he was looking for patient's father with Lucy? He spend all evening and part of the night waliking throw Chicago... He was great then.
|
|
|
Post by Praline on Feb 25, 2006 8:25:18 GMT 10
No, I'm not sarcastic LOL I really think that they were great together, but their friendship during s7 was much better that their relationship... John Carter was a part of the show since the first episode and I can't imagine how you may not like him... Sorry, but it's strange for me Do you remember when he stayed with a sick girl (befr her transplantation i think) in season 2? He didn't go for his diploma... It was sweet. Or when he was looking for patient's father with Lucy? He spend all evening and part of the night waliking throw Chicago... He was great then. I guess it is like me not understanding how people could like Carby, or Doug for that matter! I just never liked Carters "holier than thou" attitude. IMO he always felt like he was better and the whole money thing used to piss me off. For me the asshole things he did outweighed the nice things he did. I can totally see why people loved the character of Carter though, it just wasn't for me! I agree with you though on the friendship between Abby and Carter, I didn't mind that.
|
|
|
Post by dosia on Feb 25, 2006 8:51:20 GMT 10
You don't like Doug? Haha what am I doing here LOL No, i'm just kidding Doug... <love><hearts> Ha, in one week they start emiting again season 1 and 2 so I'll be able to observe better Carter... and Doug
|
|
|
Post by Praline on Feb 25, 2006 11:17:36 GMT 10
Yeah, I don't like George Clooney and it made it impossible to like Doug. I hated the way he used to strut around the ER.
|
|
|
Post by luloveser on Feb 25, 2006 14:14:01 GMT 10
i used to like him, but recently i watched i dont remeber the name but he says to abby: dont tell me what to do with my life and that was horrible. i havent seen the whole season, i've just watched the s8 and most of the s9 and the new chapters of s12, but i can say that he was really stupid with abby, and he was with susan too. :@
|
|
|
Post by dosia on Feb 25, 2006 21:59:35 GMT 10
Yeah, I don't like George Clooney and it made it impossible to like Doug. I hated the way he used to strut around the ER. I understand it. But I love Clooney's appearacnce <love> Doug in season 3 adn 4 was a really nice guy.
|
|
|
Post by kaz on Feb 26, 2006 6:39:35 GMT 10
Right Carter is a compleat pratt and i dont know aboit you but I cant wait till he finds out about Luka and Abby having a baby together I cant wait to see his reaction,cant wait to see the blood drain from his face, tears well up in his eyes, cause he is a looser and is not wanted and should piss off back to africa and stay there.The fact that he didn't have a baby makes it even better. [glow=red,2,300][evil laugh ahhhahhhahhh ahhhahhh] [/glow] screw Carter Luby forever
|
|
|
Post by elicia on Feb 26, 2006 21:24:03 GMT 10
Well I have to correct my previous post. I liked Carter in season 1. I just watched season 2 and I just hated him! I loved when Harper called him a weasel!! It was so fitting. I watched his interaction with her and just couldn't help remembering what he then did with Abby and Luka. Well there is a pattern. This guy is definitely a jerk who can't stand not to have the girl he wants!
|
|
|
Post by dosia on Feb 26, 2006 22:03:57 GMT 10
This guy is definitely a jerk who can't stand not to have the girl he wants! Oh yeah that's true!
|
|
|
Post by lubbybaby on Feb 27, 2006 0:31:59 GMT 10
Right Carter is a compleat pratt and i dont know aboit you but I cant wait till he finds out about Luka and Abby having a baby together I cant wait to see his reaction,cant wait to see the blood drain from his face, tears well up in his eyes, cause he is a looser and is not wanted and should piss off back to africa and stay there.The fact that he didn't have a baby makes it even better. [glow=red,2,300][evil laugh ahhhahhhahhh ahhhahhh] [/glow] screw Carter Luby forever You took the words out of my mouth and the thoughts out of my mind! I would love it to see Carter's face fall off when Abby anounces she's pregnant. I can see the scene in my head. Lounge, Abby & Luka are making out and he walks in. They anounced it. His face falls off and they walk out to go HOME.
|
|
|
Post by padfoot on Feb 27, 2006 2:41:37 GMT 10
I have to admit, when Luka and Abby split for the first time I did turn into a bit of a Carby, but when he left for Africa my opinion of Carter totally changed. He really is a prat and I hate him. Abby is better off without him, Luka is 10x the man that carter will ever be. And he will make a better father and *coughs* husband *coughs* heh well i can dream right? lol. I also can't wait to see Carters face when Luka and Abby break the news!! hehe yaya it will be better then when Luka told Sam!!
|
|
|
Post by Praline on Feb 27, 2006 5:27:15 GMT 10
OMG, I've been having little thoughts in my head about if Carter comes back to Chicago. I keep imagining him coming into the lounge and having Luka sitting on the couch with Abby lying down and Luka is rubbing her big baby belly!! I'd like to see his face then!!!!!!!
|
|