|
Post by Dianne on May 18, 2010 11:54:00 GMT 10
I know we got our happy ending, but I'm greedy, I wanted so much more LOL ;D ;D ;D
|
|
|
Post by suus on May 18, 2010 15:20:49 GMT 10
I know we got our happy ending, but I'm greedy, I wanted so much more LOL ;D ;D ;D Yeah, like I said some Luby movie or something? That woulde be so great, and then where we ended in season 15. I'd lovvve to see so much more! And I think it would be a great hit!
|
|
|
Post by Christabelle on May 18, 2010 20:53:43 GMT 10
Here are the Luby scene, i feel that we should have got. 1. I wanted to see a sonogram scene. Remember when Abby showed weaver, we should have seen both her and Luka at that moment. 2. The first time the baby moved/kicked we should have seen her tell Luka. Imagine his face!! 3. Graduaction day - they ending should have been Luka, Abby and Joe together. 4. and the deleted scene from 'Someone to love', both in bed and baby Joe alseep, why they deleted that from the show, i will never know! 5. and first time Joe walked, i know it was a funny scene when Neela said, 'Abbys going to be so pissed', but i would have like her, Luka or both to have seen that. See was i asking to much!! lol
|
|
|
Post by Christabelle on May 18, 2010 21:00:13 GMT 10
This is so much an unanswered question just something that really bugs me, Luby wise.
The ending of graduation day, i know what they were try to do, fooling us baby Joe had died but when you rewatch the scene again, everything said, 'Neela: She needs more time', Weaver: 'How's she holding up?'. I know what they were trying to achieve but once you realize Joe's alive, for me it doesnt make sense. It made it seem like there was more going on. Its probably me thinking way to much into but it just bugs me.
|
|
|
Post by Tara on May 18, 2010 23:42:48 GMT 10
That's a great list of scenes! I especially agree about your #1-3. Like I said before, I was an Abby fan first, so I was thrilled we got to see so much of her point of view regarding the baby, but Luka deserved just as much of a point of view and he didn't get it. Totally unfair.
I'd also add to that some early stuff, like him telling her about his family (she had probably already heard it through the grapevine at the hospital, but I assume he told her about them himself at some point). And we know she told him about the abortion, but that's also something I would've liked to have seen.
|
|
|
Post by Dianne on May 19, 2010 0:35:38 GMT 10
But they talked about it when they were lying in bed right? About his family
|
|
|
Post by Tara on May 19, 2010 0:56:24 GMT 10
Yes, they did talk about it a couple times (she asked him Daniella's (sp?) name in "A Walk In the Woods" and she mentioned his kids in S8 and they talked about it in "If Not Now") but I had always wanted to see a scene of him telling her for the first time (back in S7) about what happened to his family.
|
|
|
Post by Dianne on May 19, 2010 1:37:18 GMT 10
It reminds me of something wrong in the serie too. At first he tells about his wife Daniella and his duaghter was named Jasna. Later on, I don't remember where he said it and to who he said it. (Could it be the bed scene where Abby asked his wife's name? No don't think so, thought it was maybe to the priest) But then he says his wife's name was Jasna! I remembered that name becoz a schoolfriend of mine her name was also Jasna. How can that be possible, if the writers forget it okay, but so many ppl on the set isn't there anyone who remembered that at first it was his daughter who was named Jasna?
|
|
|
Post by Tara on May 19, 2010 3:06:29 GMT 10
That's what I couldn't understand - how *no one* else caught it. Like you said, writers make mistakes, but for nobody else to have realized it, even Goran, I couldn't believe it LOL. I know they have continuity people, was that person napping during that scene? LOL
|
|
|
Post by paigeelysec on May 19, 2010 3:47:39 GMT 10
This is so much an unanswered question just something that really bugs me, Luby wise. The ending of graduation day, i know what they were try to do, fooling us baby Joe had died but when you rewatch the scene again, everything said, 'Neela: She needs more time', Weaver: 'How's she holding up?'. I know what they were trying to achieve but once you realize Joe's alive, for me it doesnt make sense. It made it seemed like there was more going on. Its probably me thinking way to much into but it just bugs me. I agree - they were trying so hard to make us think that he didn't make it. But when Weaver says that she needs more time, maybe it was just because of all the stress and commotion over what had just happened in the recent days/weeks. And did you notice that in the scene when Luka is showing them baby pictures, it's a picture of Abby and the baby in THAT current scene? So funny! Idk if anyone else caught that.
|
|
|
Post by Christabelle on May 19, 2010 8:55:17 GMT 10
This is so much an unanswered question just something that really bugs me, Luby wise. The ending of graduation day, i know what they were try to do, fooling us baby Joe had died but when you rewatch the scene again, everything said, 'Neela: She needs more time', Weaver: 'How's she holding up?'. I know what they were trying to achieve but once you realize Joe's alive, for me it doesnt make sense. It made it seemed like there was more going on. Its probably me thinking way to much into but it just bugs me. I agree - they were trying so hard to make us think that he didn't make it. But when Weaver says that she needs more time, maybe it was just because of all the stress and commotion over what had just happened in the recent days/weeks. And did you notice that in the scene when Luka is showing them baby pictures, it's a picture of Abby and the baby in THAT current scene? So funny! Idk if anyone else caught that. I notice that everytime, too funny!! Maybe he took the picture before he left, lol
|
|
|
Post by Christabelle on May 19, 2010 9:07:49 GMT 10
Yes, they did talk about it a couple times (she asked him Daniella's (sp?) name in "A Walk In the Woods" and she mentioned his kids in S8 and they talked about it in "If Not Now") but I had always wanted to see a scene of him telling her for the first time (back in S7) about what happened to his family. I've often thought that, but then again Luka was never very open about his past, to abby, sam or even carol. I've alway felt its something private for him, he accepted what happened and moved on.
|
|
|
Post by sallins on May 20, 2010 2:48:58 GMT 10
I feel the opposite way, I can see how Goran forgot, the scene was filmed years before and he has flimed hundreds of scenes in those years, there is no way he was going to remember that, but the writers on the other hand, should have looked up in the "show bible" the name of Luka's family. We also need to remember that they are not as obsessive as we are and know that scene word for word because we have all seen it over 100 times. When I read the spoilers for that episode, I was so tempted to send an email to the ER rep at NBC but I never did. I thought the error would be corrected by the time the scene was filmed. I kicked myself for not sending the email.
|
|
|
Post by Dianne on May 20, 2010 6:45:41 GMT 10
Hihi, yeah I can understand Sallins And yes, true, Goran just reads all the scripts, he just plays what they tell him. But I'm not totally agree with you on the fact we are obsessed and seen it over 100 times coz I'm watching CSI:NY now. There's Mac Taylor, in the first epi of s1 he sits by the bed of his wife Claire, she's in a coma; 9/11 And in s3 or 4 he says to someone "I know what iit's like, my wife died at 9/11, they are still haven't found her body yet" (or something like that sentence) How a big mistake can you make?!?! I rly don't get that! It's all for the storyline I think, it's more spectacular to let someone stand by the fence by ground zero and say something like that then to tell, my wife was in coma. But come on.. that's a loss for the quality of the script/ serie, in my opinion.
|
|
|
Post by Tara on May 21, 2010 22:17:17 GMT 10
This isn't a 'burning unanswered question' - just an annoyed observation that occurs to me every time I watch S9. Carter is a rude jerk to Abby for 'interfering' in his family life in "A Saint In the City" and then two episodes later, he's trying to interfere in *her* family life by telling her she shouldn't be ignoring Maggie. Instead of taking him home and sleeping with him, I so want her to tell him to get lost in that scene LOL
|
|