|
Post by Praline on Feb 19, 2006 10:01:47 GMT 10
I noticed that quite a few of us on the boards hate Carter, I am one of them. I haven't liked him since the moment he stepped on the screen back in Season 1!! I thought that this could be out little thread to bitch and complain about him! The one main moment when I really hated Carter was when he was being such an asshole to Lucy in Be Still My Heart and even though he felt bad about her dying, it was like he never realised that if he had of listened to her she would have been OK. IDIOT!!
|
|
|
Post by lubyfan on Feb 19, 2006 10:18:19 GMT 10
Oh I'm with you wendy, for me the moment I hated him the most was when he came back from Africa with Kem. The way he told Abby about the baby was so immature. Well he really was an asshole.
Why is he coming back, it was so good without him. I'm sure the scene with him will be so boring.
|
|
|
Post by elicia on Feb 19, 2006 12:26:02 GMT 10
Wow!!! Well I just started watching season 1 again. And suddenly I remembered why I liked Carter at the beginning of the show. Then I tried to figure out when I start disliking him, I must admit it came when he started to break up Luby 1. Not that he was the only one to blame. TPTB should have let Noah leave the show earlier. This character was pointless in the last 2 seasons and just annoyed me. The Kem story was bad and after that we had to through the Wendall affair, that just did it for me...
|
|
|
Post by Praline on Feb 19, 2006 12:51:02 GMT 10
I know, I think it was all his bed hopping that annoyed me too! How many people did he sleep with?? And people bag on Luka!!
|
|
|
Post by kaz on Feb 20, 2006 4:39:12 GMT 10
I have to agree with you all he is such a The part when I really started to hate him was in 'secrets and lies' when he was drooling over Abby and leaving Susan by her lonesum and mostly when he started a rumor about him and Abby sleeping together. Come on how sad Carter. The cheek of cutting sexy Luka with that sword, i fell around laughing when Luka cut his ugly face. ASSHOLE
|
|
|
Post by Praline on Feb 20, 2006 5:28:56 GMT 10
I agree, he was a reall ass when he was dating Susan, I think he wanted it to work becuase he knew that he couldn't have Abby but he never really tried to make it work.
|
|
|
Post by dancergurl18 on Feb 21, 2006 1:52:17 GMT 10
I have to agree with you... he never tried to make things work out between him and Abby. He was always trying to fix her. Like everyone else, it also bugged me the way he told Abby Kem was pregnant. I'm hoping that Carter comes back to Chicago and Abby can tell him she's pregnant with Luka's baby. I'd like to see how that one goes over. Of course, it looks like he's just staying in Africa.
|
|
|
Post by lubbybaby on Feb 22, 2006 9:02:26 GMT 10
I have to say, I only enjoyed Carter when he was saving Luka!! Well, I think he knew he had to do it. I mean come on, the guy only drooled over Abby because he felt threatened that Luka became the biggest atraction for the women and he suddenly became just another doctor in the ER (he`s not that ugly, but come on ot`s like comparing aples and oranges) so it bewcame for him a matter of life and death to steal Abby from Luka. Siriously the whole secrets and Lies episode just proves my point. He spends the intire episode trying to look better than Luka and sinks to a whole new level of jackass. ;D I actually would love it to if he came to Chicago and Abby rubbed it in his face that her life was way better without him. Since I love when she`s all pissed and mocking people I would really love an episode like that. Siriously, someone dress her up, really sexy with a boy baby in her arms (It just has to be a boy for a scene like this) and let her tell him she`s better off without him. Dude, I`m getting an idea for a fic. See ya!
|
|
|
Post by Praline on Feb 22, 2006 15:08:00 GMT 10
OMG, It is like you are reading my mind. My fav part is when Luka starts reciting Hamlet in Croatian, like it wasn't funny enough to have Carter's reaction to the fact that Luka was Hamlet, he looked like such an idiot!! And then the whole sword fight, OMG, and I loved that Abby told Susan about the lie he told, I am sorry but why the hell did she ever date him???
|
|
|
Post by lubbybaby on Feb 22, 2006 23:48:13 GMT 10
I loved that Abby told Susan about the lie he told, I am sorry but why the hell did she ever date him??? What lie? I can't for life remeber! But I also can't understand why she dated him. I always had a feeling it was because she was jealous Luka was still in love with his late wife, (That's the impression I got when she shouted out he was married to a ghost. It obviously bothered her) maybe Carter was a "If you can't drool over me, Carter can" But she soon seemed to realise she acted stupid. She does spend full S9 running around to figure out if Luka is OK.
|
|
|
Post by Praline on Feb 23, 2006 5:22:27 GMT 10
Carter lied to Rena about having slept with Abby. Practically the whole hospital found out and it never happened.
|
|
|
Post by lubbybaby on Feb 23, 2006 7:18:40 GMT 10
Right! Yeah, I remember that. I remeber wanting Luka to hear this one and see his reaction, but they never wrote anything about that. Would have been fun though
|
|
|
Post by Praline on Feb 23, 2006 15:19:26 GMT 10
It would have been great to see Luka's reaction if he had ever found out, but unfortunately he never really know how much of a jurk Carter was. It still annoys me how he sticks up for him sometimes!!
|
|
|
Post by dosia on Feb 24, 2006 8:29:05 GMT 10
Ok. I have a diffirent POV... but yours is very... intersting LOL I like Carter but the idea with the next episode with him drove me mad. Come on, he leaved this show! I rather see Susan, Doug, Carol or even Rachel again than him now! About carter: I didn't like the way how he ended his relationship with Abby. By a letter... Like a schoolboy... In addition he was the one who really wanted to be with Abby, the whole season 7 he jelaously was looking at her with Luka, then he even told her it. At season 8 - Abby was ready to be with him, but suddenly mister Johnny wanted somebody without a history ;D Season 9, Carby season, unfortunatelly I didn't see it, only their scenes, I thought that they were cute, but after their dinner in 'The Advocate' (am I right? It was in this eppie?) when he had a ring for her - he annoyed me so much! Firstly - why didn't he proposed, he was talking with Maggie about being with Abby etc... But secondly - he wanted to propose but he had never told Abby what he feels! There wasn't any 'I love you' or anything... Stupid... And when he came back with Kem - He hurted Abby so much! And his last episode in season 11 - 'The Show Must Go On' - he could talk with Abby and say her goodbye more privately, without Ray and Neela around! Look, Abby broke up with Luka (or he with her, what the diffirence...) and they were still great friends. They were talking, laughing etc. And after her relationship with Carter - wow, how many 'carby' scenes we had? Only few... I still like his character. I just sometimes disagree with the plot and this what he was doing. But I really loved his firsts seasons! (His hair <- BIG LOL) And his friendship with Abby during the season 7 - their trip to Oklahoma, charity date, and then when they went to Luka's apartament to change his tank LOL This moments I really liked.
|
|
|
Post by lubbybaby on Feb 24, 2006 11:42:27 GMT 10
I didn't like the way how he ended his relationship with Abby. By a letter... Like a schoolboy... - why didn't he propose, ! There wasn't any 'I love you' or anything... Stupid... And when he came back with Kem - He hurted Abby so much! And his last episode in season 11 - 'The Show Must Go On' - he could talk with Abby and say her goodbye more privately, without Ray and Neela around! Look, Abby broke up with Luka (or he with her, what the diffirence...) and they were still great friends. They were talking, laughing etc. And after her relationship with Carter - wow, how many 'carby' scenes we had? Only few... This is how I interpreted all of this. : 1st The whole scene with Carter not proposing, he said something about people changing and bla bla bla (I really don't listen to him much) and she said she didn't believe in people changing ... ... (When they talked about this, I don't know why, and it might just be me, but I was taken to that S8 scene when Carter says to Abby that she hadn't broken up with Luka, she was not over him) So if she doesn't believe in change... ... ... I think this is why he didn't propose. 2 conected to 1 The friendship with Luka was far more her worrying and carying for him and getting pissed like she did (Hindsight. And that scene really showed something between them, actually most Hindsight scenes showed the indications that things between them wasn't finished.) 3 The whole breakup thing between Carter and Abby, the whole after break up between them just proves my point. He really didn't love her at all, I mean if he's able to just turn his back, write a letter to break up with her, and not care at all to look twice or to keep a friendship ... ... ... And the goodbey scene... ... ... dry, cold. I guess that's all. (Look I'm not beeing rude siriously. I had a bunch of people curse me because I've said this. But I honestly don't mean to be rude, it's just how I think)
|
|