Andrea
Marquise of Luby
LUBY Forever and Ever
Posts: 233
|
Post by Andrea on Jan 22, 2008 3:14:45 GMT 10
Thank you, Andreea !
So nice to hear that some people don't think I'm systematically trying to say negative things when all I'm doing is to point out that the writing is badly done, sometimes without any continuity with the past lives of the characters.Merci beaucoup! No problem, just telling the truth.... BRILLIANT
|
|
|
Post by abigailangel on Feb 9, 2008 11:33:56 GMT 10
I'm not Sam's biggest fan but I can understand her reaction completely.
She feels let down and she is angry at Abby for possibly putting patients at risk (Abby - didn't get a chance to repond to her question before the others started hugging her and leaving the room) so she doesn't know if Abby had drink stashed around the ER. Which I think I would be angry about if I were a co-worker.
I think she's also angry on Luka's behalf as she's more Luka's friend than Abby's and is considering him in this whole equation. To be fair to her she's tried to open up to Abby a few times - when Abby was pregnant and recently when Joe fell. It's Abby in her self defensive mode that hasn't let her become more friendly.The only time i remember her opening up to Sam was about the abortion she'd had.
However I don't think Sam appreciates Abby's history (has she ever came across Maggie when she was manic ? - I don't think she was around then) and why she(Abby) is so guarded and unable to let people in. I'd like to see a conversation sometime in the future between them where some of this is said.
I also thinks Sam see's Abby as having an easier ride of it than she's had (ie being a Dr , having her partner stick around with her Baby) and she's probably thinking and I've not resorted to drink. I'm sure even medical professionals don't all understand the addiction to alcohol some people have.
I think at least Sam's reaction is honest. I'm not convinced some of the others won't say more behind her back (should we get any more episodes).
On the up side of the episode I felt proud of Abby . She was incredibly brave to tell everyone and definitely out of her normal comfort zone. I agree with some peole though in that it did look lile a 'last working day' episode (although I hope not a last episode ever ) Er just wouldn't be the same for me without Abby . She's been my favourite character almost since she joined and I don't think anyone will ever replace her. I'd like to see a rosy ending for her either at the end of season 14 or if it extends into season 15.
|
|